The Lenovo Skylight: A Glimpse Into a Forgotten Future

The Lenovo Skylight is one of those fantastic stories I’ve been lucky enough to share on my channel. If you haven’t seen the video of me unboxing this rare, unreleased ARM laptop, check it out below—it’s a true time capsule.

Like many of my deep-dive videos, I gather as much information, research, and firsthand accounts as possible to tell the fullest story. But every once in a while, I stumble across gems that don’t quite fit the main narrative or deserve their own spotlight. This article is where I get to share those.

The Vision Behind Skylight

One such example is this interview with Peter Gaucher, which offers rare insight into the device’s origin:

Skylight is a device that was inspired by the user’s usage scenario. In 2008, we were considering a strategy for a new netbook-like device that was based on cloud computing. Recent smartphones not only have high processing power but also have long battery life. We thought that we could develop a device with a larger screen that still had sufficient portability and Internet connectivity by using this technology. In fact, many iPhone users say they want a larger screen for watching videos. In addition, many consumers, especially young people, no longer want a full-featured Windows-based PC. We looked for market opportunities and found that Qualcomm had a similar vision, so development began. The development concepts were: 1. High portability, 2. Good design, 3. All-day use, 4. Instant on, 5. No fan or HDD. These concepts could not be realized by netbooks based on Intel processors.

This wasn’t just a quirky experiment—it was a serious attempt to rethink mobile computing. Lenovo saw a future where ARM processors, cloud services, and sleek design could converge into something revolutionary.

Design That Dared to Be Different

For those curious about the design, I highly recommend watching my interview with David Hill. He discusses how the team, along with legendary designer Richard Sapper, crafted Skylight’s striking look.

It also had a lasting impact on further designs. The keyboard that appeared on Skylight was essentially the prototype of what would become the modern six row ThinkPad keyboard. You can learn more about that in this article.

Jun
17

ThinkPad Keyboards: Classic, Modern and why you can love them both

A quick way to start a debate One thing that will get long-term ThinkPad users talking is the differences between all of the ThinkPad keyboards and which version is best. This can be a hotly debated topic with a lot of feelings, nostalgia, personal preference and use cases but there are some things I’d like […]

Tech Details and Limitations

There’s been interest from the Linux community about Skylight’s operating system. While I’ve identified the code base and the original developers, the system is heavily locked down—likely due to its demo-only nature. Accessing the SanDisk chips under the keyboard might be possible, but documenting the OS is beyond my current skill set.

The swollen battery may be replaceable. Given that the unit is not completely sealed in plastic and the construction details are on a sticker on the membrane that makes up part of the casing, the battery can very likely be rebuilt. Since the battery is already in a ‘damaged’ state, this might be something worth trying down the road.

The Smartbook That Never Was

Skylight wasn’t alone. Around the same time, other manufacturers were experimenting with ARM-based smartbooks—HP’s Compaq Airlife 100 and Toshiba’s AC100 come to mind. However, none of them managed to surpass niche releases or demo stages.

While it may have been an idea ahead of its time, it got journalists of the day discussing the possibilities. Brian Barrett, in an article, stated that customers would never get to decide for themselves if they wanted a smartbook, as it died before it hit the market.

What’s vexing is that it’s starting to look as if the broad consumer market will never really get a chance to decide for itself whether it wanted smartbooks. Third-party delays and a commanding tablet lead decided for them. The smartbook example tells we’re at a point where the industry can only stand one revolutionary device at a time. And frankly, that feels more like a coup.

Final Thoughts

The Lenovo Skylight may never have reached consumers, but its story still resonates. It’s a reminder that innovation doesn’t always follow a straight path—and that sometimes, the most fascinating devices are the ones that never got their moment in the spotlight. I’m grateful to have shared this glimpse into what could have been, and I hope it inspires others to keep digging, keep documenting, and keep celebrating the forgotten corners of tech history. If you’ve got stories, memories, or even your own rare devices, I’d love to hear about them in the comments. Until next time—stay curious.

For years, it’s been an open secret among tech enthusiasts that a used ThinkPad is one of the best values in computing. While you may not be on the bleeding edge of technology, a pre-owned ThinkPad is often far more durable and feature-rich than a brand-new consumer-grade machine you’d find at a big box store. As these machines complete their first life cycle, they still have plenty to give and can handle everything the average person requires from a PC. Between their legendary reliability and robust build quality, customers can often save a significant amount, getting a premium experience for a fraction of the cost.

Today, Lenovo is stepping into this space with the announcement of its new “Lenovo Certified Refurbished” program, a move that looks to bring some of that pre-owned market in-house.

What makes this program stand out is the Lenovo-backed warranty bundled with every device. This is a game-changer for many customers. Often, when I help people find devices, they are hesitant about used products, seeing them as immediately inferior. The term “refurbished” has earned a bad reputation over the years, much of it deserved. However, Lenovo’s commitment to quality and support may convince people who would never consider a used device to explore the savings and peace of mind this program offers.

A few other highlights are that all PCs in the program are Windows 11-capable. They will be rated in terms of condition as either Premium, Good or Standard. A one-year warranty is applied as standard with an optional three-year warranty extension.

Given the program is just starting, I imagine it will be available in more areas as time moves forward. To learn more about the program, you can visit: https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/certified-refurbished/

A Page Turned for Foldable PCs

I had a hunch that Lenovo’s ThinkPad X1 Fold 16 was heading for the “withdrawn” list, especially as I watched the available models dwindle on their website. A quick check of the PSREF page’s withdrawn section confirmed it: both the original X1 Fold and the X1 Fold 16 are officially discontinued. That means they’re no longer for sale or in production.

Years ago, I had the opportunity to test a pre-production sample of the ThinkPad X1 Fold 16, and I genuinely enjoyed my time with it. If you’re curious to learn more about my experience, you can find a link to my in-depth article and a video playlist below:

Jan
04

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Fold 16 Gen 1: The Road of Innovation

The Folding Machine Folding devices, even years after being introduced are somewhat of an oddity. I have been the first person I know to own or handle any and I cannot recall seeing one in public at the end of 2022 and the owners I met in 2023 I could count on one hand. I […]

Now, this wasn’t going to be a machine for everyone. But for me, someone who appreciates compact and smaller devices that don’t need a ton of computing power, it was a delight. For context, I’ve been daily driving a ThinkPad X1 Nano G1 since its release, so I have a soft spot for light and compact machines. I don’t need loads of power on the go, and if I do, I’ve got other devices for that. I completely get that not everyone has multiple devices or even wants to carry them, though.

The Challenges of Innovation

The withdrawal isn’t entirely surprising, especially considering the complexities involved in bringing such a device to market. I once spoke to Luis Hernandez, former VP of Lenovo Commercial Product Solution Development, who shed some light on the hurdles. He emphasized how challenging it was to manufacture, yet he firmly believed in its potential:

I’m telling you that the X1 Fold 16, it’s a great product but it was hard, it was hard to do. You can imagine foldables are very hard to do in the phone industry, you can imagine in the PC, they’re bigger screens so it’s even more challenging, but I love that product. I think that product is revoluntionary and eventually it will be a big, a big part of the computer notebook segment in the future as we figure out ways of… bringing the price down as we drive more volume. 

While I never got my hands on a production version of the X1 Fold 16 Gen 1, the factors that likely limited its widespread appeal are clear. The high cost and unique form factor inherently narrowed its potential audience. Making the keyboard and pen optional accessories in many markets further inflated the price, pushing it even further out of reach for many. After all, if you’re investing that much, you likely want the complete experience, not just the base model.

Furthermore, the specifications were already a generation behind upon release, and without any specific AI features to market as the AI boom began, it quickly felt dated. The choice of a fanless cooling solution, while enabling a sleek design, meant performance suffered under heavy loads—a clear trade-off that prioritized portability and quiet operation over raw computing power. Given the intended audience, however, this decision makes sense; it was never designed to be a workstation.

If Lenovo does pursue another iteration, I believe a few key changes would be essential based on what I’ve seen people say about the production version:

  • Stronger CPU and Improved Thermals: A more robust processor, coupled with a better cooling solution or thermal management, would be crucial to boost performance and reduce throttling.
  • Inclusive Accessories: The keyboard and pen should be included in the box, not sold as separate, costly accessories.
  • Integrated Stylus Storage: Exploring ways to store the stylus within the device would enhance convenience and portability.
  • Targeted Use Cases: Continue to deeply study the market to identify the best fit for this unique device and offer specific, compelling use cases that resonate with that audience.
  • Cost reduction: Much like when the ThinkPad X300 was released, there was a desire to make it more cost-effective. This ultimately led to the creation of the X1 and then the X1 Carbon. The same thinking needs to apply here.

New Patents Emerge

At the time of writing this article, I combed through the US Patent Public Search to see what clues of the future may be waiting. I found an interesting patent (US 20250231595 A1), filed on November 4, 2024, and published a few days ago (July 17, 2025), which details a display assembly for a foldable PC.

Images from Patent US-20250231595-A1

Another patent (US 12363843 B2) was published July 15, 2025, that details a hinge for a foldable device that is a possible match for the mechanism shown in Figure 5 above. Both of these recent patents support a previously submitted patent (US 20250028363 A1). The mechanisms in these latest patents are somewhat similar to patents filed years prior, but there are some key changes that suggest ongoing refinement. The most recent one has an emphasis on additional components that act as a buffer and support behind the display to manage bending stress. 

Before we all get too excited, patents do not tell the whole story. Years ago, there was a new revised patent for the butterfly keyboard that hasn’t gone anywhere… yet.

Jun
26

Will Butterflies fly again?

This article has been updated on 27 June 2021 to include new information. It appears last year Lenovo filed a new Butterfly-style keyboard patent and it was recently approved earlier this month by the US Patent Office. You can look it up on your own using the #11,029,723 and unsurprisingly it references John Karidis’ existing […]

It isn’t uncommon for an idea or device to receive a patent and have it not produced. Another possible example of this is a patent (US 12332690 B2) approved at the same time as the ones above for a tablet that attaches to the back of a laptop A cover.

What’s Next for Foldable ThinkPads?

The journey of the ThinkPad X1 Fold series highlights the inherent challenges and immense potential within the foldable PC market. Its discontinuation underscores the need for continued refinement. However, Lenovo isn’t giving up on this innovative form factor. The recent patent filings for display assemblies and hinge mechanisms strongly suggest they are actively exploring how to build a better, more reliable, and ultimately more compelling foldable PC. 

What are your thoughts on the future of foldable PCs? Do you think they’ll eventually become a mainstream option, or remain a niche product?

ThinkPads are synonymous with their sleek black design. This was a conscious design choice by Richard Sapper, who famously wanted the ThinkPad to stand out from the ‘hideous beige’ computers of its era, envisioning it like a sleek, black ‘cigar box’ that revealed its complexity only when opened.

Back in the beginning, there were, in fact, white or beige ThinkPad laptops for specific markets.  For example, the ThinkPad 700C has beige or white variants for the German market. So while some media outlets are calling this announcement the “first white ThinkPad”, this is not accurate.

If you want to learn more about this, I have a comprehensive article covering the subject of the originals.

Oct
22

The ThinkPads that weren’t Black

Update: This article was updated on March 18, 2023 thanks to the help of Dan Basterfield who worked for IBM UK PC Company. His knowledge has helped increase the overall accuracy of this article. ThinkPad enthusiasts will likely know that at the very beginning of the history of ThinkPad, black was not the only colour used […]

Fast forward to today, and Lenovo China has announced what is called “White Moonlight,” which is a limited edition run of the ThinkPad X9 in what they call “moonlight white.”

The buzz began early this July, as ThinkPad’s official account on Weibo teased ‘White Moonlight’ with intriguing images of a watch and a violin, Other images were added later, leading up to the announcement.

Earlier this month, the website videocardz.com believed this was the launch of new white ThinkPad models. They included a mockup of an image that appears to combine elements of the two images above with what appears to be white ThinkPad X9 units. Turns out they were correct.

Jan
09

Lenovo experiments at CES 2025

Over the last few days, thanks to media credentials, I’ve been bombarded with CES 2025 information. Unfortunately, given when the media dates fell, I couldn’t attend in person. Perhaps next year. Lenovo presented an interesting showing this year in the sense that there weren’t many groundbreaking show-stoppers. That being said, here are a few highlights […]

 

This will be a limited edition run called the Yuanqi Edition (Yuanqi is a term used in Traditional Chinese Medicine), which is the first of the limited moonlight white machines being potentially planned. With black keys on the keyboard and a stark white and clean finish, it prompts an interesting question: Is Lenovo China positioning this model to aesthetically challenge Apple’s MacBook in the domestic market?

For those concerned that this marks a permanent shift away from the ThinkPad’s core design philosophy, don’t worry. Lenovo China has a well-established history of releasing unique, regionally-focused machines that don’t always see an international launch. This strategy allows them to experiment with new features, designs, or market segments tailored specifically to Chinese consumer preferences, without necessarily impacting their global product lines. That isn’t new. The ThinkPad Neo 14 is a great example.

While the ‘White Moonlight’ ThinkPad X9 is undeniably sleek and fascinating, it raises an interesting debate about tradition versus innovation in design. Personally, while I appreciate the novelty and elegance of the ‘moonlight white’ finish, I still find myself gravitating towards the classic, professional, and timeless black ThinkPad. Its understated power and iconic design remain, for me, the true essence of what a ThinkPad represents.

 

The TrackPoint may leave ThinkPad one day, but it isn’t today.

The Background

For those of you following CES and Lenovo’s product lineup, the ThinkPad X9 got people talking. In a previous article, I covered how journalists compared it to Apple’s design language.

Jan
09

Lenovo experiments at CES 2025

Over the last few days, thanks to media credentials, I’ve been bombarded with CES 2025 information. Unfortunately, given when the media dates fell, I couldn’t attend in person. Perhaps next year. Lenovo presented an interesting showing this year in the sense that there weren’t many groundbreaking show-stoppers. That being said, here are a few highlights […]

The big question was, of course, where was the TrackPoint? A leak before CES sparked much speculation about this machine, which was branded a ThinkPad but was missing one of its most iconic features. Again, I covered this story in a previous article.

Dec
27

A ThinkPad without a TrackPoint?

The Situation So let’s get this out of the way. Leaked images are floating ahead of CES 2025 showcasing a device called the Lenovo ThinkPad X9. This ThinkPad does not have a TrackPoint. ThinkPad X9 14/15 pic.twitter.com/2WXGyxJl9h — WalkingCat (@_h0x0d_) December 24, 2024 Several news outlets have picked up the story, including Notebook Check, one […]

There have been ThinkPad devices in the past that have deviated from the core design philosophy, even so much to not have the TrackPoint. Some of the original machines didn’t have it either such as the tablet computers like the ThinkPad 710T and 730T. Other models like the ThinkPad 220 featured a trackball of sorts and the ThinkPad 300 also did not have a TrackPoint. Several other tablets like the ThinkPad Helix 2 and Tablet 10 featured keyboards in their lineup that did not have a TrackPoint.

All that to say, what the ThinkPad X9 has done is not the first time we have seen a ThinkPad without a TrackPoint, but it has been a while and it was a surprise all the same. I am a huge TrackPoint user and it is one of the essential components of why I use a ThinkPad.

New Information

Here is where things get interesting and special thanks to Saoto on X/Twitter for posting this article, thus bringing it to my attention. Long-time viewers of the channel will recognize the name as the person who makes custom 3D-printed TrackPoint caps.

In an article published by PC Watch Japan on January 14, 2025, Tsukamoto Yasumichi, Executive Vice President and Head of Development at Lenovo Japan was interviewed about the ThinkPad X9. There was some significant messaging in this interview that I am surprised was not communicated during CES regarding their goals for the X9.

The author, Kazuki Kasahara, who should be praised for their direct journalism, asks outright about the TrackPoint:

“The ThinkPad X9 is a product primarily targeted at customers who have not been ThinkPad customers until now. For example, it is a product that was planned and designed in the hope that customers who are familiar with other companies’ products will recognize the basic value of ThinkPad, such as high productivity and robustness, and consider it as an option when they switch to ThinkPad. In that case, we thought that it would be better for customers to have a larger click pad than the TrackPoint, so we decided to remove the TrackPoint.”

Yasumichi Tsukamoto “The shocking debut of the controversial TrackPoint-less ThinkPad X9: Who is it for?” (PC Watch Japan)

The naming conventions are also cleared up and I think the explanation that Tsukamoto provides is an excellent one.

“The ThinkPad X9 brand name was chosen to indicate that it is the polar opposite of the ThinkPad X1. If the ThinkPad X1 was the flagship product for existing ThinkPad customers, then the ThinkPad X9 is the flagship product for new customers,”

Yasumichi Tsukamoto “The shocking debut of the controversial TrackPoint-less ThinkPad X9: Who is it for?” (PC Watch Japan)

The Takeaway

I think many fans of ThinkPad and its traditional design would agree with Tsukamoto’s assessment that the X9 is indeed the polar opposite of the X1. While many will still not agree with it being called a ThinkPad given how far it strays from expectations, if the X9 helps more people and companies get introduced to what many have come to appreciate about the iconic brand, then maybe it will pay off. 

Tsukamoto seems to be aware of the stir that the X9 caused and Kasahara asked an important question about the TrackPoint’s future:

“Traditional ThinkPad models, such as the X1 series, P series, T series, X series, and L series, which are aimed at existing customers, will continue to be equipped with TrackPoint.”

Yasumichi Tsukamoto “The shocking debut of the controversial TrackPoint-less ThinkPad X9: Who is it for?” (PC Watch Japan)

If you want to hear more about the development of the ThinkPad X9, consider watching Kevin Beck’s sit down with Tsukamoto which was published on YouTube a few days ago.

In the spirit of 100% transparency, the keyboard featured in this video was supplied by EPOMAKER and not personally purchased. My goal is to review this product objectively.  I accepted something of monetary value to produce the article, the product itself.


EPOMAKER is a company that I have featured on the channel before. They have made some good keyboards that I have had the opportunity to test.

They asked me to test their Dynatab 75 which comes in a standard and a dot matrix display. While I didn’t get the chance to test the dox matrix display, I did see something that caught my eye: the EPOMAKER Sea Salt Silent Switches.

The box. Note that this box is used for both models. This may be important if this is being given as a gift as they might be disappointed to find it doesn’t have the fancy display that is advertised on the box.

I hadn’t tested a keyboard built for silence until now, so I agreed to give it a spin.

In the box

Inside the box we have the keyboard, a dust cover (yes, do not throw out the plastic cover, it is supposed to stay with the keyboard), a USB A to USB C cable, a combination key cap and switch puller and instruction manual.

The Dynatab 75 unboxed.

Key Features

The Dynatab 75 sports a variety of features, which I have summarized below:

  • Integrated Slot for Devices: The keyboard features a built-in slot designed to hold iPads, tablets, or phones,
  • Compact 75% Layout: The 75% layout includes 84 keys.
  • Gasket-Mounted Structure: The keyboard incorporates a PC plate, Poron sandwich foam, IXPE under-switch padding, and bottom base foam.
  • Hot-Swappable Sockets: Compatible with most 3/5-pin switches.
  • RGB Backlight: The keyboard features RGB backlighting.
  • Connectivity: Users can connect seamlessly using Bluetooth, 2.4GHz wireless, or a Type-C wired connection.
  • Fast-Charging Chip & 5000mAh Battery: Equipped with a fast-charging chip (supporting up to 2A rapid charging).
  • Double Shot PBT Keycaps: The keycaps are made of durable double-shot PBT material, sporting an MDA profile.

User Experience

The keyboard feels the sum of its parts, which is plastic. The board feels light in the hand despite the 5000mAh battery. Thankfully it doesn’t move around the desk.

Unsurprisingly this is the quietest keyboard I’ve tested so far, likely due to the several layers that make up the keyboard coupled with a very quiet switch. It was very comparable to the silent switch offerings from other companies like Cherry. The feeling of these switches has been compared to a premium membrane keyboard, but membrane keyboards tend to have a tactile bump whereas these switches are smoother. Some may find them a bit spongey without that firm, bottom-out feeling to them but I didn’t mind them.

The absence of several keys may put off individuals that use every key on their keyboard and I am one of those people. I have a separate numpad so I am not missing that functionality when I am testing other keyboards. At the very least I have Print Screen on this keyboard. The software allows for rebinding but with no additional keycaps in the box, it means I have to keep track myself. Speaking of keycaps, while it is compatible with Mac machines, it does not feature Mac keycaps to swap out, which are often included with other keyboards I have tested.

Typing speeds were a bit slower for me. 52 WPM was the average I was getting. I’m not too surprised by this result as I’m not used to a keyboard that feels like this or sounds like this and I suspect that the audible queue that I am used to from my other keyboards being absent impacted my experience.

There are some nice touches on this keyboard beyond a very quiet typing experience. The 2.4 GHz receiver is stored behind the cover plate on the top right of the deck. It is always nice to see a manufacturer think about where this can be safely stored and not leave it up to the user to keep track of it.

Another nice feature is the adjustable feet with two positions on the bottom of the deck, giving you three angles total to tilt the keyboard.

Adjustable feet, two positions.

The tray that is designed for tablets will fit an Apple iPad Mini on its side or a standard Apple iPad in portrait orientation only, neither of which I own. Other reviewers pointed out that portrait mode for the larger tablets led to them tipping over. The Samsung tablet I had to test with fit vertically (portrait) but then it blocked my desktop screen. I was also unable to touch the tablet at all without it tipping over.

A Samsung T700 tablet in portrait orientation in the tray. Touching it even slightly results in it tipping over.

It fit my Google Pixel 6a with its case but stood nearly vertical making it difficult to read from many natural angles. I also worried that a few vibrations in that upright posture would have it fall onto the keyboard. If my phone did not have a case, I suspect this would be a non-issue. I’m not alone on the mixed feelings around the tray with several reviews on their website citing devices not fitting due to cases or dimensions. In short, if this is a selling feature for you, measure twice, and buy once.

Perhaps in another version of this keyboard, they can provide a power pass-through so you can plug in a charging cable so your device can at least be getting a top-up while wedged into the slot at the top of your board.

The width of the tablet/phone slot at the top of the keyboard.

Conclusions

When not on sale, this keyboard is priced at $89.99 USD which doesn’t make it the cheapest board out there. With the most unique feature being the tray at the top of the keyboard not being able to accommodate all devices, it needs to be a perfect match for your setup in my mind to be worth the price of admission. The dot-matrix variant clocks in at $139.99 USD. While the keyboard has a good feel going for it in terms of the silent keys, so long as you don’t mind the unique feel, this can probably be achieved on other, less expensive boards. It has certainly raised my awareness of the possibilities of silent and softer switch profiles, but I won’t be switching to this keyboard full-time unless I can repurpose the tray at the top.

Over the last few days, thanks to media credentials, I’ve been bombarded with CES 2025 information. Unfortunately, given when the media dates fell, I couldn’t attend in person. Perhaps next year.

Lenovo presented an interesting showing this year in the sense that there weren’t many groundbreaking show-stoppers. That being said, here are a few highlights that did catch my attention.

Some Firsts: Rolling Screens and CUDs

This rollable screen concept appears to be releasing as the ThinkBook Plus Gen 6. While the idea of a rolling or expanding screen intrigues me, I am unsure what problem this solution solves. It may very well be one of those things that you need to see and use to understand the application. Unlike the Yoga Slim and Yoga Book 9i below, this ThinkBook does not have a product page or pricing information but many outlets report a spring launch at a hefty $3,500 price tag.

The Yoga Slim 9i has indeed some slim display bezels (98% screen-to-body ratio) but what I found catching my attention was the CUD (Camera Under Display). You still have the bump at the top to hold the higher resolution camera that people now demand in a post-pandemic world, which I’m not opposed to given the function it provides. The top cover being made from glass has me worried that it might be challenging to keep looking new. These will start at $1,759.99 USD in February 2025.

Yoga Book 9i Continues

It is good to see that this dual-screen device did well enough to earn it another generation. I saw one of these in person when I went to Lenovo TechWorld 23 and seeing it in the flesh and speaking to the person using it helped me understand why they enjoyed the device. Pricing for this new generation starts at $1,999 USD being available in May 2025. I wonder if this means one day we might see a ThinkPad X1 Fold 16 Gen 2; that would be something I’d like to see as it was a lot of fun to test one of the prototypes.

Jan
04

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Fold 16 Gen 1: The Road of Innovation

The Folding Machine Folding devices, even years after being introduced are somewhat of an oddity. I have been the first person I know to own or handle any and I cannot recall seeing one in public at the end of 2022 and the owners I met in 2023 I could count on one hand. I […]

The ThinkPad X9

For many of you who follow me, this is the elephant in the room. ThinkPads, generally speaking, follow a certain design language. They are generally dark colours, more specifically available in black and have traditionally featured a TrackPoint. To get technical, there were devices branded ThinkPad way back like the 710T and 730T ( If you want to see a wonderful restoration of one of these devices or other cool things, you should check out polymatt’s channel on YouTube) that were tablet computers that had no keyboard and, therefore no TrackPoint. Other machines like foldable tablets and Z series have also strayed from these cornerstones over the years.

Back to the main event. The ThinkPad X9 was leaked ahead of CES 2025 and I covered some thoughts on this in an earlier article:

Dec
27

A ThinkPad without a TrackPoint?

The Situation So let’s get this out of the way. Leaked images are floating ahead of CES 2025 showcasing a device called the Lenovo ThinkPad X9. This ThinkPad does not have a TrackPoint. ThinkPad X9 14/15 pic.twitter.com/2WXGyxJl9h — WalkingCat (@_h0x0d_) December 24, 2024 Several news outlets have picked up the story, including Notebook Check, one […]

There is some neat technology in the ThinkPad X9 including its cooling system, the haptic TrackPad and more. The big question many people is why is this called a ThinkPad. Given what people have come to expect from the brand, I think this is a fair question. Several news outlets that are at CES 2025 and have spent time physically with the device mention very specifically it is two things “It is a ThinkPad” in one breath and then mention “Apple” at some point in the article. Historically, these comparisons have been made before but not so directly. It could also be a trend in technology journalism to compare everything to Apple. If you want some excellent coverage of CES 2025, I recommend Andrew Marc David’s channel.

“This ultraportable from Lenovo is indeed a ThinkPad, but it appears to bridge the gap between professional and consumer laptops—prosumer, if you will—dropping the TrackPoint device in the keyboard as a telltale sign.”

Hands On: Lenovo’s ThinkPad X9 Aura Edition Is a Mighty Swipe at MacBook Air (PCMag)

“Lenovo has unveiled two new ThinkPads: the X9 14 and X9 15, both Aura Editions equipped with Intel Core Ultra processors and slim designs. But what they don’t offer might be the most interesting thing about them: namely, Lenovo’s signature red TrackPoint. Instead, they use a haptic trackpad without the ThinkPad’s usual discrete button for a distinctly MacBook vibe.

No doubt, it’s a ThinkPad, through and through. It’s tested to MIL-SPEC 810H durability standards. It offers a Thunderbolt 4 port on each side of the machine, making it easier to arrange docks and displays to your liking. And the design allows access to the SSD and battery to facilitate repairs and replacements.”

Lenovo’s ThinkPad X9 drops the TrackPoint (The Verge)

It is a bit of a wonder to wrap one’s head around the possible decision-making process involved in branding this machine a ThinkPad rather than a ThinkBook, which design-wise, seems to share more in common. Part of me wonders if this is an attempt to avoid what Dell has recently done with renaming all of their PC products. For example, if Lenovo wanted to produce a premium laptop product, that would limit their established product lines. While IdeaPad, Yoga and ThinkBook are good units at their price point, ThinkPad is considered by many to be the most premium business machine Lenovo offers.

So what happens when Lenovo wants to make a laptop of equal quality to a ThinkPad, geared towards business customers and wants to do something different? Do they create a completely new premium line of business laptops or do they use one of their existing brands and establish a new series? Both have pros and cons. 

  • This device in terms of specs, target audience and quality is too premium for the ThinkBook or IdeaPad range.
  • Creating a brand new product line entirely is likely more difficult to market to business customers and may make it more difficult to sell.
  • Using the ThinkPad brand, which is very well established, has risks as those expecting a specific design may be alienated by this design.
  • So do you create a new machine class, the X9 and put it under your premium laptop line or do you try and create a brand new product line?
The keyboard keys have a very subtle touch of what would be considered the modern ThinkPad keyboard.

I suspect this is why it is called the X9 and not part of an established ThinkPad line that features more historically recognizable features like a sleek black chassis and red TrackPoint. I believe this hypothesis is further supported by the fact they are releasing a series of X9 accessories rather than exclusively relying on the existing ThinkPad catalogue of accessories. The X9 branding is also present on the camera bump. It wouldn’t be hard to imagine that if the X9 does well, it could be its own product line separate from ThinkPad but of equal quality.

Lenovo X9 Charging GaN Dock, Lenovo Multi-Device Wireless Mouse (X9 Edition), Lenovo TWS Earbuds (X9 Edition), Lenovo Origami 14” and15.3” X9 Sleeve

I do not believe that the X9 will set the trend for future ThinkPad design and I look at it like I would look at the Z13; a testbed that diverts from traditional ThinkPad design but has some of the DNA that makes them amazing machines.

Given the choice between what Dell has recently done with their brands, I’d rather have a ThinkPad without a TrackPoint than the brand-new Lenovo Pro Max Premium Carbon G13…

Jan
07

Dell Ditches Iconic Brand Names in Rebranding Move

Dell has made a surprising and potentially controversial decision: to abandon its long-standing and iconic PC brand names. Gone are the days of the XPS, Latitude, Inspiron, Precision, OptiPlex, and G-series. All these familiar names will be replaced by a new, tiered system, leaving only Alienware standing as a distinct brand. Odd decision to go […]

The ThinkPad X9 will be available in February 2025 and starts at $1,399 for the 14-inch variant.

Dell has made a surprising and potentially controversial decision: to abandon its long-standing and iconic PC brand names. Gone are the days of the XPS, Latitude, Inspiron, Precision, OptiPlex, and G-series. All these familiar names will be replaced by a new, tiered system, leaving only Alienware standing as a distinct brand.

Odd decision to go with this tiered system as outlined in the image above and below; placing machines into three main categories with three sub-categories each. Many news outlets have made the comparison between this move and Apple’s move to describe the different models of the iPhone.

One attendee reportedly asked why Dell “didn’t choose something original, because you essentially have Apple’s branding here.”

Another said Dell’s naming choices were “a lot” like Apple’s. “Aren’t you just following them?” they asked.

Dell reportedly defended its branding change, with executives responding that no one owns the words “pro” or “max” and that these are universal terms.

Dell’s chief operating officer Jeff Clarke said that the move to change names resulted from extensive research involving “tens of thousands” of people.

Dell Defends Itself After Being Questioned About Imitating Apple (Entrepreneur)

While the intention behind this move remains somewhat unclear, it seems like Dell is aiming for a simplified and more streamlined product lineup. However, the decision to bury the history and brand equity associated with names like XPS and Latitude is a significant gamble. The XPS 13, for example, was a renowned and highly regarded laptop, and its legacy now risks being obscured under the generic “Dell Premium” label.

Dell’s new naming structure.

One of the first products to emerge under this new system is the “Dell Pro Max Micro” – a name that certainly doesn’t inspire confidence in terms of clarity and memorability.

It’s impossible to predict whether this rebranding will be successful. Dell is betting big on simplifying its product lines and enhancing customer understanding, but the risk of alienating loyal customers and losing brand identity is undeniable.

 

2024 has been a good year. While I was hoping to get more content out and share more with you, several things ate my free time for breakfast and it didn’t quite work out as intended. Despite that, the statistics from both YouTube and this website paint a positive picture. Views are holding steady and only a slight drop in subscribers per year. Funny enough, the number of uploads for 2023 and 2024 is the same.

Website statistics are likely a result of search engines and other bots combing the content and learning from what I write here. I wrote very little, likely as a result of doing a lot of writing for school, so doing it as a hobby was less attractive. My goal is to write more articles in 2025.

YouTube Stats for the year 2024.
Stats for laptopretrospective.com

As has been my tradition, I will break down each month and pick a highlight for me.

January

January was a slower start to the year, but it had me feature the P53, which was capable of 128GB of RAM—a very impressive piece of gear. Workstations aren’t super common around here, so looking at one, especially a P-series, is always fun. I remain grateful for Rob Herman helping me frame what makes a workstation an important addition to a laptop lineup. As an aside, he was a familiar face I met in person at Lenovo Tech World 2023.

February

Speaking of workstations, this highlight for February came in a nice carrying case that helped sell the idea that this was true portable power. It isn’t often we see hard cases for laptops so this was fun to look at for that reason as well. The owner had a portable monitor tucked away in the lid making for a comprehensive setup.

March

March saw the release of the series of interviews I did with Luis Hernandez, a wonderful storyteller and all-around great human being. He worked for both IBM and Lenovo, retiring as the VP of Lenovo Commercial Product Solution Development. You can see the full interview below:

April

This month was mainly releasing the interviews I did with Luis in terms of main channel content. I did feature the L14 G2 which had more modularity than the T series of the same generation. Thankfully the T series now has just as much. Looking at a modern L series was still very educational.

May

A conversation with David Hill is always a highlight. In May we discussed the Lenovo Skylight project and David shared stories of its development and how Richard Sapper created this sleek-looking laptop that was never released. 

June

This video may be close to the highlight of the year for me, being able to bring you a sealed Lenovo Skylight, open it and tour the operating system. Special thanks to David for locating it and for Tommy to help me get it to Canada. In terms of rare machines, this is pretty high up on the list.

July

Lots was going on in July but the video that stands out is releasing the full interview I had the pleasure of doing with Tom Hardy for the 30th anniversary of ThinkPad several years ago. The video contains just over 30 minutes of additional conversations and stories. It is worth the watch to hear some of Tom’s stories about the challenging and rewarding environment that design work brings.

August

August is a draw between two smaller laptops. The Toshiba T1910CS with the weird trackball attachment was a lot of fun to film and was the first laptop I filmed in my renovated film space. The runner-up is the ThinkPad 240X which was the first Japanese-exclusive ThinkPad I’ve featured on the channel and one of the smallest ThinkPads to be featured as well.

September

The IBM TransNote is a strange device with an even stranger story. One day I will release the video of the one I have in my collection, I promise. David Hill remembers working on it with Dr. John Karidis of butterfly keyboard fame on the ThinkPad 701C. It is clear to see why the machine didn’t make it to another generation but it clearly left an impact as many people I have interviewed over ther years reference this device.

October

My highlight here is an upgrade to my tool kit. To make a long story short, I follow David Hill on X/Twitter and enjoy his Design of the Day posts. One post was for a company, HOTO showcasing a flashlight. After a little digging, I saw they made a screwdriver kit and wanted to treat myself. I’ve been enjoying it ever since. Honestly, I should probably treat myself a little more often than I do. I imagine that the production quality would continue to improve if that were the case. The challenge is how to improve production quality without adding additional work and not impacting the speed of production. Being a one-person crew that does everything, every additional step needs to pay off and then some for it to be worth slowing things down.

November

This next highlight is thanks to Dan Basterfield, who is an amazingly knowledgeable and kind individual with quite an excellent ThinkPad collection. He digitized some service tapes like the one I did for the ThinkPad 701C and asked me to share them with the greater community. You can expect to see another release from this VHS collection soon in 2025.

December

The last item to bring up would have to be the LG-IBM video. Back in 2022 I covered the story of LG-IBM in detail on this website, but didn’t have a machine to present. This changed and I was able to create a video showcasing not only the IBM ThinkPad 570 but also probably the strangest rebrand in the IBM lineup at that point.

Jul
28

The Strange History of LG and ThinkPad (The Story of LG-IBM)

Update This article was originally published July 28, 2022. It has been updated to include a video showcasing an LG-IBM ThinkPad 570 that I featured on the channel. It contains references to this article in its originally published form. A Sticker If you are like me, you have spent some time looking through Hardware Maintenance […]

Thanks everyone for watching and reading and I will see you next year!

The Situation

So let’s get this out of the way.

Leaked images are floating ahead of CES 2025 showcasing a device called the Lenovo ThinkPad X9.

This ThinkPad does not have a TrackPoint.

Several news outlets have picked up the story, including Notebook Check, one of my favourites. You can read their article here.

The bottom line is, we do not know a lot about this device, where it will be released or if it will be released. Concept devices are common at tradeshows like CES and TechWorld and many do not make it to production. The bendable phone I saw at TechWorld 23 is a good example.

Nov
04

My Lenovo Tech World 2023 Experience

I was able to attend Lenovo Tech World 2023 thanks to my participation in the Lenovo INsiders program. My travel and accommodations were covered and there was no cost to me to go to Austin, Texas. As part of my efforts to ensure 100% transparency, I am disclosing this information at the top of this […]

Another thing to consider is the odd nomenclature; X9. This does not fit within any existing product line-up which is encouraging that this might not be a mass rollout or an idea that would even stick. The TrackPoint is also part of the accessibility feature package that they advertise on the ThinkPad lineup.

Why does it matter?

There are many possible explanations for this but the reason this move is seen as strange to so many ThinkPad users and fans is, that this is one of a few features that make ThinkPad iconic and not just another brand. You can take the badge away and still know a ThinkPad is a ThinkPad based on the sleek black colour and the red TrackPoint present on the keyboard.

I do not believe this is the end of the TrackPoint, I will make that clear. That would be the equivalent in my mind of prying the Jaguar off the hood of the car (An expression I picked up from David Hill, Former Chief Design Officer & Vice President of Experience Design at Lenovo). That example might not be a good one to make any more with Jaguar’s recent advertisement that famously featured no actual car or Jaguar.

Jerry Paradise who retired from Lenovo in March 2024, said this quote during ThinkPad’s 30th anniversary celebrations as reported by PCWatch.

Q: Will the TrackPoint continue to be implemented in ThinkPads?

Paradise : That’s right. We believe that the TrackPoint will be implemented forever as long as ThinkPad exists. It is our promise to our customers, and we believe that it is an iconic part of the ThinkPad brand and part of the design.

As an aside, Jerry Paradise is on my wishlist of individuals to interview as his history with ThinkPad runs very deep. I imagine he has a lot of amazing stories he could tell. Perhaps one day.

What is the history?

The TrackPoint, an isometric pointing device embedded in the keyboard of ThinkPad laptops, was invented by Dr. Ted Selker while working at IBM Research in the early 1980s. He drew inspiration from research on mouse-pointing devices and hypothesized that a finger-operated pointing device integrated into the keyboard would be faster and more efficient than a mouse. Selker collaborated with colleague Joe Rutledge to develop the TrackPoint. They conducted research and experiments, discovering that a non-linear transfer function improved selection speed by preventing cursor loss. This approach challenged conventional thinking at the time and led to disagreements with other researchers in the field.

Several factors contributed to the significance of the TrackPoint:

  • Improved efficiency: The TrackPoint offered a significant speed advantage over trackballs and mice. Users no longer had to take their hands off the keyboard, saving valuable time and maintaining focus.
  • Space saving: The compact size of the TrackPoint made it ideal for use in confined spaces like bank teller stations, airplanes and other places where space is limited.
  • Accessibility: Users with shaky hands found the TrackPoint’s overshoot prevention algorithms particularly beneficial and only required one point of contact to manipulate the mouse cursor.
  • Brand identity: The TrackPoint became a signature feature of ThinkPad laptops, contributing to their brand identity and attracting a loyal following.

I’m very fortunate to have the history of the TrackPoint from the sources that were there when it all happened. I had the chance to speak to both Dr. Ted Selker and Tom Hardy and both had stories to tell about this iconic device that has been on essentially every machine to carry the ThinkPad name.

Why remove it?

I can think of a lot of reasons why people would want to remove it and I suspect that most of it revolves around cost. It is no secret that making room for the TrackPoint comes at a cost both financially and spatially.

  • Changing user preferences: As touchpads have become larger, more responsive, and feature-rich, many users have come to prefer them over the TrackPoint. The wider adoption of touchpads has led to some manufacturers prioritizing them over the TrackPoint to cater to evolving user demands.
  • Cost considerations: Including both a TrackPoint and a touchpad increases manufacturing costs. To reduce expenses and potentially lower the price of their laptops, a manufacturer might choose to eliminate the less popular pointing device.
  • Design trends: The trend towards thinner and lighter laptops has put pressure on manufacturers to maximize internal space. Removing the TrackPoint and its associated hardware can free up space for other components, such as larger batteries or improved cooling systems.
  • Competitive pressure: If competitors are successfully selling laptops without TrackPoints, a manufacturer may feel pressured to follow suit to remain competitive. This is particularly true if the manufacturer wants to appeal to a wider customer base who may not be familiar with or prefer the TrackPoint.

So while the reasons to remove it are many, we are still talking about one of the most visibly iconic features of any laptop brand in the history of laptops. That would be like taking one of the most well-known social media brands in history and renaming it. Alright, I promise to stop with the not-so-good examples.